A Jew in CPT-Palestine II: Hebron

The night before the Christian Peacemaker Team interfaith delegation left Jerusalem for the West Bank, a late-arriving Philadelphia delegate was detained at Ben Gurion airport.   You could say he was targeted for  “davening while Black.”

Here’s some context.  I first met Wilbur in 1994 when I’d moved back to my hometown of Philadelphia and realized I’d reached a point in my life where I was ready to join  a synagogue. I’d heard that Brian Walt had founded congregation that took risky positions on Israel and Palestine.  It was somewhere in the western suburbs, but I was determined enough to take the train.    A few seats over, I spotted an African American wearing a kippah and a Jewish star earring.  His name was Wilbur.  He was heading in the same direction, to Mishkan Shalom.  We’ve been friends ever since.

When Wilbur arrived at Ben Gurion airport, the agent at Passport Control noted the kippah, typed something on her computer, and gestured him towards a corner room.  An hour later, he was interrogated at length by another agent.   What was he doing in Israel (touring the Holy Land with a group of Christians and Jews).  Is he Jewish (Yes).  Did he convert? (You know you’re not supposed to ask me that).  It’s my job to ask you that.  (Would you ask me that if I were white?).  Yes.   At one point, they asked Wilbur what was in his bag, and he pulled out his prayer-book and copy of Pirkei Avot.   Another agent asked “Do you know Queen Mother Esther?” which might have been a reference to the Hebrew Israelites.  Wilbur had no idea what he was talking about.

Wilbur in Bethlehem, kippah in place, relaxing with the author and Chelle Bruhn
Wilbur in Bethlehem, kippah in place, relaxing with the author and Chelle Bruhn

Over three hours later, Wilbur emerged—outraged and exhausted—the kippah still defiantly on his head.   I’d woken up to the news, and could hear Wilbur’s distinctive baritone voice carrying over from the sitting room.   We’d known that this might be a risk; I’d shared an article I’d found through Facebook about African American Jews detained two weeks before.  Part of me wished he’d followed my advice, played it safe, and taken off the kippah, but that wasn’t in Wilbur’s nature.

Two days later, Wilbur took off the kippah.   He was asked to do so.  We were in Hebron.

He was also in the process of taking off his Jewish star earring and anxious that the hole might  close up if he couldn’t find a place-holder.   He looked as though he was in pain, but he cooperated.   As you might have guessed, I pushed the question.  After all, we were a delegation of Christians and Jews.  Wasn’t part of the point to let people in Hebron know that not every Jew in America is a settler?    At first, I was told that no Jews were allowed in the Old City; we later learned that wasn’t true.  The Hebron Protocols designate that district H2, under total Israeli military and civil control,  Jews have utter, arrogant freedom of movement, far more than Palestinians who’d lived there for generations. Then, I was told that only Jews who are settlers are permitted in the Old City.

The truth is probably closer to this:  if someone wears a kippah in the Old City of Hebron, even if he’s black and wears a Jewish star earring, he is—de facto—a settler who happens to be staying in the guest apartment of CPT-Palestine.  Who needs more trouble?

IDF soldier and settlers in Hebron
IDF soldier and settlers in Hebron

Hebron certainly is populated by very visible men in kippahs.  They’re white, and well-armed, swaggering around the shuttered streets around their settlements.  Their kippahs are enormous, actually, looking almost like Muslim skullcaps, and from them emerge wild side-locks.   A lot of them are American, just like us, and in the fortress-like Shuhada Street or hillside compounds where they’ve staked their claims, their signage is in unapologetic English. They’re guarded by IDF soldiers who seemed—to our eyes—to be primarily Jews of color, skinny kids who don’t look thrilled to be there.

All told, there are around four-hundred Jewish settlers in the Old City of Hebron, drawn by the proximity of Abraham’s tomb, but perhaps even more by the prospect of avenging the 1929 Massacre; certainly it was those two elements that led to Baruch Goldstein’s rampage in the mosque on the site of that tomb in 1993.  After that rampage, part of the mosque became a synagogue, and the two halves are divided by bullet-proof glass.   What really got to me, though, were the two prayer-roads, divided by a high green fence.   One side is for Palestinians, the other for anybody else.  The Palestinian side is strewn with garbage.

“Sit in” outside Palestinian home as settlers try to get a jump on pending Israeli Supreme Court decision. CPT staffer Mona speaks with International Solidarity Movement volunteers (note their keffiyehs).
“Sit in” outside Palestinian home as settlers try to get a jump on pending Israeli Supreme Court decision. CPT staffer Mona speaks with ISM volunteers.

The morning we arrived, a family of settlers was staging a sit-in outside a house they hoped to claim, pending a final Israeli Supreme Court decision.  The Palestinian owners were inside.   A few keffiyeh-wearing folks from the International Solidarity Movement kept guard on the porch.  Apparently, the night before, the settlers had started singing, and the Palestinians and ISM folks tried to out-sing them, leading to a kind of Battle of the Bands that would be funny if there weren’t so much human suffering involved.  Settlers expropriate these homes if they stand empty for any length of time, or they use a straw-man to make a purchase, or they simply forge documents.  Then, neighboring houses are expropriated by the IDF to keep the settlers safe.

The Christian Peacemaker  Team office is right next to just such an IDF compound, through a courtyard full of chickens—some in cages, and some roaming free and eating rotten pomegranate halves from the nearby juice-cart.   Because the compound blocks the way for neighbors, they routinely take a detour through the CPT office on their way home.  We stayed in the back, in a grim apartment with a kitchen stove that never worked.   The actual staff apartment wasn’t much less grim, though it did have a working coffee maker.  When they remembered, they’d unlock the door and let us use it.

CPT staffer Cody explains everything
CPT staffer Cody explains everything to the delegates: “to be perfectly honest”:

I developed a kind of collective crush—totally unrequited—on the CPT Hebron staff:  Mona, a Palestinian whose family was expelled from Jaffa in 1948, who filled us in on a previous night’s IDF “shit show” night-raid in a matter-of-fact sardonic drawl,  Rachel, a beaming super-sweet American Midwesterner whose mother was part of our delegation, Yousef, a Hebron native who was recruited by CPT when they found him leaping from roof-top to roof-top with his enormous camera, and Cody, a chain-smoking, dangerously charismatic Palestinian cowboy from Michigan who slouched his way through the Prayer Road patrol where we watched for human rights violations.  Cody would answer every question with the phrase, “Well, to be perfectly honest,” and it was Cody who laid out the routine of life in the Old City where Israel provides no infrastructure, crime and drugs are rampant, and everyone had a prescribed role:  IDF, border patrol, international groups  like the CPT,  Palestinians, and even settlers.   The encounters feel ritualized and routine, that is until something disrupts them.  A new IDF battalion rotates in.  A settler decides to play with that M-16 he’s been dragging around the Old City.   A Palestinian boy throws a stone.  That’s when the “shit show” starts.

So when these heroes, who live in what I can only compare to a Freedom House in Mississippi, ask Jews who will be gone after six days to pretend they aren’t Jews, who are we to kick up a fuss?   In fact, after my rather terse request, our delegation leader did make a point of announcing the group’s composition when we met with organizations.   What did I want, to walk around with a big yellow star on my chest?

Hebron by night: the view from Leila’s roof. Note the water tanks, which aren’t found in settlements where Israel provides both electricity and running water. The lights are probably from Kiryat Arba, the enormous settlement outside of town.
Hebron by night: the view from Leila’s roof. Note the water tanks, which aren’t found in settlements where Israel provides both electricity and running water. The lights are probably from Kiryat Arba, the enormous settlement outside of town.

Perhaps.   From the start, CPT put our group in touch with extraordinary people who were doing what Freedom Movement people call “spade work,” scrambling over the scrap-heap of Hebron resources, writing grant after grant to NGOs, and struggling to revive life in the Old City, prepare crumbling kindergartens for the start of a school year, put cameras into the hands of Palestinians (“our M-16s”), so human rights abuses are immediately recorded and sent out on the You Tube on the Human Rights Press.   We met with Laila Slemiah who leads the collective Women in Hebron, who cooked us the best meal of the trip– an overturned pot of fragrant rice and chicken which is apparently called Maqloobeh.  She led us up the stairs of her 800-year-old house to a steep roof where a few of us fought vertigo and we all felt a rich, wholehearted welcome and acceptance.

The acceptance felt real.  These people were our Virgils leading us through the Israeli occupation’s version of Dante’s Inferno. Their sanity, intelligence and courage was beyond dispute.   They all knew we were part of an interfaith delegation.   But what would happen if I asked the kinds of questions Jews at home would want answered: for example whether there was a connection between armed Palestinian resistance and the closures on Shuhada Street, or about the pervasive and constant fire-crackers that mimic gun-shots but seem to be Palestinian children’s favorite form of entertainment, or about whether life in Hebron was actually easier before Oslo when West Bank Palestinians routinely crossed the Green Line, or even what it would be like if– say– somebody in a kippah walked politely into Leila’s shop and bought a pillowcase.

That Saturday morning, we were guided by a representative of the Hebron Rehabilitation Committee to get a better understanding of the strategic positions of settlements in the Old City.   As went through a checkpoint to the courtyard by the Muslim and Christian prayer-space that now divide the Ibrahimi Mosque, our guide apologetically reminded the Jews among us not to self-identify, and we entered the mosque-side.  I heard the sound of the Shabbat service coming through the synagogue wall and and wondered:  what was I doing here?   What was the purpose of entering this mosque under false pretenses?  Would it help people in Hebron?   Those Jews  on the other side are praying and I don’t share their conception of God or idol-worship of land, or casual violence or much of anything with them, I hope.  But  I share those words and melodies.  I felt moved and nauseous and confused; what was I supposed to do with what I was feeling?

CPT staff and delegates at the August 8th Settler Tour. Note our red hats, IDF troops, and the distant white shirts of the Orthodox Jews who often come every week and-- we’ve heard-- usually don’t pay much attention.
CPT staff and delegates at the August 8th Settler Tour. Note our red hats, IDF troops, and the distant white shirts of the Orthodox Jews who often come every week and– we’ve heard– usually don’t pay much attention.

Then, there’s what CPT calls the “settler tour”, an obscene circus that shuts down several streets in the Old City. That day, around forty orthodox Jews  took what I suppose was their traditional afternoon Sabbath walk as IDF soldiers invade Palestinian homes to stand guard on rooftops, cars are stalled, and shops are shuttered tight.  I assume the “tourists” walked up a street through a series of tunnels and courtyards, and pointed out sites from the 1929 massacre.   At the time, I was back with CPT and the rest of the international observers, as Palestinian boys yelled and rammed their bicycles into our legs and asked us to take their pictures. All the while, what I really wanted to know was this: What was Hebron’s Jewish Quarter? What was life like there? Where was the butcher-shop or mikveh or synagogue?

It might have been then that I realized:  who stops me from asking these questions?   I stop myself.  After that day, I began identifying myself as a Jew and initiating casual conversations with our guides as we walked from place to place,. I’d hedge a little, but the answers were usually direct.   Of course Jews who aren’t settlers are allowed in the Israeli-controlled Old City.  The Israeli peace group Women in Black is always there.   No, not many Palestinians embrace nonviolence as resistance; frankly, they’re concerned with the hardships of life under occupation and don’t think on those terms; they just survive.   Yes, Jews can absolutely enter Palestinian-controlled towns; what keeps them out isn’t a check-point, but a state of mind.  Indeed, fireworks are a long-standing Palestinian tradition especially for weddings.   And indeed, for Palestinians, the Right of Return is Absolute, even if it means displacing a Jew who lived in a home post-Nakba over seventy years ago.

A few days later, we toured Shuhada Street with one of its long-time residents, Hani from the Hebron Defense Committee.   His family had lived in Hebron for many generations, and they’d been olive-oil exporters, among the wealthiest in Palestine.  Now, his home was hemmed in by settlements and army compounds, and his land– much of it expropriated as an Israeli archeological site– still contained charred trunks of trees settlers had poisoned before they’d set them on fire.   At one point, he opened up space for questions from the group.  Conscious that this was the first time I’d asked one of my pointed questions publicly, I said, “Was your family in Hebron during the massacre of 1929?”

Indeed, the his family had been present.  In fact, hei said, they were mentioned in a book called Siddur Hebron, which lists households that sheltered and saved Jews.   He also insisted that no one from Hebron itself could possibly have been involved in the massacre.  The Jews were their neighbors.

Hani Abuhaikal and Israeli border guard debate Hebron’s history in Hebrew.
Hani Abuhaikal and Israeli border guard debate Hebron’s history in Hebrew.

At that point, one of the Israeli border guards who’d been standing nearby interrupted in very halting English:  “What are you talking about?”

I think I might have said, “I asked him about the massacre in 1929.”

The soldier said to “You people killed them.”

“Why would we kill them?  They were our neighbors?   People don’t kill their neighbors,” our guide said.

Then, the soldier’s English gave way, and for the next ten minutes, Hani and the soldier spoke in Hebrew; I am the product of at least ten years of actively not learning this language, and I would have given anything to turn back the clock, because our guide was too engaged to make more than the most cursory attempt to translate.   He did make it clear that it was impossible that any Muslim in Hebron would take part in the massacre, and in fact had heard that it was a British militia who’d wrapped their head in keffiyahs.    All the while, I stood there with my jaw hanging open, grateful that one of us was taping this for posterity, feeling like something important was happening, though I couldn’t say why.

On our last day in Hebron, after a meeting with Youth Against Settlements in their office high above Shuhada Street, saved from settlers in a rare instance of  Israeli High Court justice, the leader of our delegation leader got a call on her cell phone   There was something happening below; we needed to stay put for a while.   Our group sat, silently and heard what was unmistakably machine-gun fire.  These were no wedding fire-works.  It felt like hours had passed and I can’t guess what was going through the heads of other delegates, but I felt I kept thinking:  this isn’t a video or article in Haaretz.   This is where I am right now.   I’d never felt so present in my life.  What would it be like to live with this every day?  What would it be like to be a child who only knew this?  Could it ever become normal?

Then the phone rang again.   A Palestinian had just been released from prison after fifteen years.  The machine-gun fire had been in celebration.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: